Home Dialogue Q&A: Do you believe that free elections (one where even an incumbent can be defeated) can change a country?

Q&A: Do you believe that free elections (one where even an incumbent can be defeated) can change a country?

Dialogue

Our previous question was: "Do you believe that free elections (one where even an incumbent can be defeated) can change a country?"

Opinions were mostly divided. Of those who answered the question, 53% thought that such elections could bring positive change to the country; 43% thought they could not. Around 4% did not have an answer.

The idea for the question was derived from the occasion of the Ukrainian presidential elections. The discussions and commentaries surrounding that election, especially in the former Soviet space, went in two directions.

One side considered Yushchenko’s defeat symbolic of the disgraceful end of the orange revolution; the other side used just the opposite argument—that precisely on account of the orange revolution was it possible for the CIS region to have the only presidential election where not only was the acting president defeated in consecutive elections, but in the next stage of the election, the acting prime minister and the opposition leader were able to take the lead, with the result of the opposition leader defeating the acting prime minister. While, for elections in CIS regions, the acting presidents are never “defeated” in consecutive elections—they are either removed by revolution or rule for two consecutive terms, or even more.

For the first time in the span of 18 years, elections in the former Soviet space (with the exception of the Baltic States) had an acting president removed from office in democratic elections that were approved by OSCE observers; this, however unprecedented, is still a hopeful occurrence.

Analyses of Yushchenko’s ruling years differ. One can talk at length about the problems of those years and about corruption, but it’s obvious that at that time in the Ukraine the system of government was able to develop counterbalances such that in the end normal democratic, consecutive elections were able to occur for the first time in the CIS region; this, in every case, should be difficult to consider as anything but a positive attainment.

 

Add comment


Security code
Refresh

Civilitas Polls
With the support of Norwegian and German governments, a few months ago the Civilitas Foundation began to conduct polls throughout Armenia. The results of the polls will be made available to the media and will serve as the topic of public discussions.

read more

Facts for Thought
Border crossing balance in Armenia by country of citizenship
2010 2011
Russia +5896 +2705
Georgia +1075 +2320
Iran +2054 +666
Germany +164 -42
France +395 -138
USA -74 -353
Total +10556 +5306
Comments & Sources
 
Our Projects
DAIRY PRODUCTION ENHANCEMENT
The objective of the project is to contribute to the overall improvement of dairy production practices in Armenia by providing machinery to dairy farmers for increasing their productivity and income and improving their living standards.
The objective of the project is to contribute to the overall improvement of dairy production practices in Armenia by providing machinery to dairy farmers for increasing their productivity and income and improving their living standards.
Civilitas Library
The Civilitas Foundation Library -- a collection of political, historic and philosophical works -- open to all who need it. Do you want to donate a volume?
See the Civilitas Amazon wish list.
Podcasts
Civilitas Blog

The Civilitas Community shares stories about daily challenges and successes. Today: Lost in Istanbul

Read the blog

Civilitas Spotlight
civilnet-logo-1
Screen-Shot-2012-01-11-at-2.43
Civil.am
Civil.am - your guide to civil society activity in Armenia - is a project of the Civilitas Foundation. Take a closer look to better understand what is already being done. Identify potential partners and cooperation possibilities. Support existing programs to increase efficiency. Encourage new programs to foster development.
 
Newsletter Sign Up
* Email
First Name
Last Name
Country
* = Required Field

Civilitas Around the Web
facebook twitter linkedin flickr Civilitas on Scribd livestream youtube